Well first, it takes a heck of a lot of courage to share the truth about being a victim of abuse. Who are you to think that someone owes y
When it comes to domestic and sexual violence, in an entire lifetime, most of us are not asked to be in a position that would make a final life-changing determination with this information like:
Judge or even jury member
Employer
But most of us are in a position of:
family member
friend
acquaintance
faith group member
colleague
Nearly all of us can make a positive difference in the lives of Survivors who choose to disclose.
And yet, I do not think that people realize just how difficult they make it for Survivors of harm and abuse to speak out.
When people ask, “Why now?” in response to someone disclosing abuse that occurred a long time ago, they may not realize the weight or harm of their question. In fact, sometimes, it sounds pretty cold and arrogant.
“Why now?” is not commonly asserted to any other crime victims; yet Survivors must deal with this question too frequently.
On the surface, it seems to inquire about timing, but beneath it, the question often reflects discomfort, doubt, or a misunderstanding of the complexities of trauma and disclosure.
Here’s what “Why now?” may really signify:
1. Doubt or Skepticism
- What They Might Be Thinking:
“If this really happened, why didn’t you say something sooner?” - What They’re Really Asking:
Is this story credible? Can I trust this person’s account? - Why It’s Harmful:
This question can unintentionally imply disbelief, causing the Survivor to feel invalidated or accused of fabricating their experience. If you are just a spectator to this person’s life, what does it matter to you? Why be mean when you can get busy on your own stuff?
2. Discomfort With the Topic
- What They Might Be Thinking:
“This is hard for me to hear. Why bring it up now?” - What They’re Really Asking:
Why do I have to deal with this now? - Why It’s Harmful:
It shifts the focus away from the Survivor’s pain and courage to the listener’s discomfort, making it harder for the Survivor to feel supported. It is understandable to find listening difficult. This stuff is heavy and hard. If you can, try to make sure that the person has someone else to turn to who is qualified to deal with trauma more effectively.
3. Misunderstanding the Process of Healing
- What They Might Be Thinking:
“Why didn’t you address this earlier?” - What They’re Really Asking:
Why couldn’t you deal with this sooner? Why has it taken this long? - Why It’s Harmful:
It disregards the complex barriers Survivors face—fear, shame, denial, societal pressures, or simply not being ready to confront the trauma. Even with commitment and dedication, the process of healing can take an entire lifetime.
Many Survivors are not just healing from the violent acts but also unhealthy responses to the crime as well as dysfunctional relationship dynamics in their families. Further, some Survivors struggle with debilitating physical and mental chronic illnesses stemming from the attack(s).
4. Curiosity Without Sensitivity
- What They Might Be Thinking:
“Why now?” - What They’re Really Asking:
What happened recently that made you decide to speak up? - Why It’s Harmful:
Even if well-meaning, this curiosity can seem intrusive or dismissive, as if the timing needs to be justified for the disclosure to matter. Sometimes we may never know what prompted a Survivor to feel safe enough to come forward when they did. Nevertheless, the time is always right to be supportive. Supportive can look like refraining from criticism of a victim of violence and harm.
The Reality of Disclosure Timing
Survivors of abuse often delay disclosure for numerous reasons:
- Fear of Judgment: Survivors worry about being blamed, disbelieved, or shamed.
- Trauma Responses: Many cope by suppressing memories or minimizing the abuse to survive emotionally.
- Power Dynamics: The abuser might have been in a position of authority, leaving the survivor feeling powerless to speak out.
- Readiness to Heal: Coming forward often requires a safe environment and emotional strength, which may take years to develop.
A More Compassionate and Humane Response
Instead of asking “Why now?” consider responses that validate and support the Survivor, such as:
- “Thank you for trusting me with this.”
- “I’m so sorry this happened to you.”
- “I’m here to listen and support you however I can.”
These responses focus on empathy rather than interrogation, creating a safe space for the Survivor to share their story.
.png)
Why People Should Think Twice About “Why Now?”
“Why now?” risks shutting down that bravery.
Instead, shift your focus to what matters: supporting the Survivor, affirming their experience, and honoring their trust.
After all, we are human beings, not sharks who smell blood in the water and start targeting people.
