HomeFemale Safetyfemale health civil rights

When the System Calls It a Catfight: The Silencing of Black Lesbian Survivors

A Survivor-centered truth from an advocate who has witnessed too much silenceLet’s tell the truth—because lives depend on it. I’ve worked

She Didn’t Stay Because She Didn’t Know. She Stayed Because She Did.
10 Truths About Grooming: What It Is and What It Is Not
Sisterhood Isn’t a Cage: Reject the Love Bombs That Protect Male Violence

A Survivor-centered truth from an advocate who has witnessed too much silence


Image credit: Cottonbro/Pexels

Let’s tell the truth—because lives depend on it.

I’ve worked with Survivors for over 30 years. Women from every background and every walk of life. And I’ve sat across from too many Black lesbian Survivors who were navigating something no one warned them about:

It wasn’t just the abuse that harmed them. It was the system’s response to their pain.


⚠️ What I Witnessed as an Advocate

When Black lesbians tried to seek help—real help—they were often met with:

  • Mockery: “Sounds like a catfight.”

  • Minimization: “Two women fighting? You’re probably both just emotional.”

  • Dismissal: “There’s no real danger here. No man involved.”

  • Confusion: “Who’s the abuser? Who’s the victim? You both look fine to me.”

  •  Harassment: “Why don’t you two make up so that we can all be friends. Ya know?”

It didn’t matter if there were bruises.
It didn’t matter if she was terrified.
What mattered was that the harm didn’t fit the story the system was ready to hear.

And so, many of them stopped telling it.


🛑 The Systems Were Not Built for Black Lesbian Survivors

These women faced judgment and disbelief:

  • In courtrooms, where judges didn’t know how to handle “two women fighting” and defaulted to criminalizing both

  • In hospitals, where staff made jokes or asked invasive questions

  • In shelters, where they were either turned away or met with suspicion

  • In communities, where they feared outing themselves would bring more danger than staying

For some of them, the abuse behind closed doors was terrifying—
But the thought of being laughed at, locked up, assaulted, or left unprotected in public was worse.

That’s what kept them quiet.
That’s what influenced their decision to stay.


🧭 Why Patriarchy Is Still at the Center

Even when there’s no man in the relationship, patriarchy still runs the system.

  • It tells women that if there’s no man present, it can’t be “real” abuse

  • It erases lesbians from conversations about danger, control, and survival

  • It punishes women for defending themselves, especially when they don’t fit the “ideal victim” mold

  • It creates systems that serve men by default—and ask everyone else to adjust

  • It questions all of her choices up until that point.
  • It continues to blame her for not being someone else’s version of a “good girl.”

Let’s be clear:

Black lesbian Survivors are not confused. The system is.
The system is confused about what real harm looks like when women aren’t performing fear the way it expects.


💬 Survivor Voices (Voices Like Theirs)

“I called the police after she tried to choke me. We were both arrested. I was the one with the bruises.”

“People say abuse is about power. Then why didn’t anyone help me when she had all the power and I had none?”


✊🏾 We Must Expand the Frame

Black lesbian women do experience domestic violence.
Not in theory. In truth. In homes. In silence.

And they deserve:

  • To be believed

  • To be protected

  • To have access to trauma-informed services

  • To be seen as Survivors, not side notes

We must create spaces where they don’t have to first explain their humanity before they’re helped.


🌟 If You Are a Black Lesbian Survivor

You do not need to fit someone else’s mold of “victim” to deserve protection.
Your pain is valid.
Your story is real.
You are not alone.
And you do not need to suffer in silence to protect someone else’s comfort or reputation.

You are not “too much.”
You are not “just dramatic.”
You are not the “aggressor” because you defended yourself.

You are a Survivor.

And we see you.

*Note: This post isn’t meant to exclude any other race of lesbians. However, recently the violence in these specific relationships has been framed in a way that doesn’t center the voices and experiences of Black lesbians who attempt to get help from therapists, faith communities, law enforcement, shelters, and other community service providers. That’s not a complete picture of a problem. That’s not how we arrive at a solution.


[wesurviveabuse.com] | [rosaschildren.com] | [survivoraffirmations.com]
Share if you feel safe and ready—your voice might be the lifeline someone else needs. And if you do share, remember to cite the messenger. Words carry legacy.

Author

Spread the love
Verified by MonsterInsights