“Not Like Us”: You Cannot Claim Our Legacy While Declaring Western Medicine the Only Answer

There is a pattern that deserves daylight.

Some movements wrap themselves in the language, symbolism, and moral authority of the Black American freedom struggle. They echo the rhythm. They borrow the posture. They invoke the history.

But when the conversation turns to medicine — especially Western medical authority — something shifts.

As though one system, one framework, one professional lens now holds the final word on complex human realities.

Our Legacy Was Never Built on Automatic Deference

The Black American movement has never been rooted in polite acceptance of this –historically exploitive abusive and harmful– institutional authority.

It has always carried a sharper insistence:

👉 Question the system
👉 Interrogate the evidence
👉 Demand accountability
👉 Name harm, even when it unsettles comfort
👉 Refuse silence disguised as “trust”

This did not emerge from rebellion for rebellion’s sake.

It emerged from survival.

Medical Systems Are Not Above History

Black Americans did not develop caution toward medical institutions through imagination or ideology.

It was learned.

Tuskegee was real.
Forced sterilizations were real.
Dismissed pain is real.
Maternal mortality disparities are real.

Entire communities were told outcomes were “within standards” while watching loved ones suffer preventable harm.

So we learned to ask:

Standards for whom?

Puberty, Identity, and Childhood Are Not Simple Territories

When the subject is children — developing bodies, emerging identities, emotional distress — complexity multiplies.

Puberty is uncomfortable for every human being. Some more than others. 
Teens try on identities. Children wear fairy costumes to the grocery store and forget all about it by the time they are adults.
And distress? Depression? Anxiety? Well that has a lot of roots.

Psychological, social, developmental, neurological, familial.

Reducing that landscape to:

“Medical intervention is the answer”

or worse,

“Medical intervention is the only responsible answer”

short-circuits the very discernment our history taught us to practice.

Medicine Is a Tool, Not a Doctrine

Western medicine is powerful.

Healing. Relieving. Life-Saving. Revealing.

It also:

• Revises itself
• Carries uncertainty
• Produces unequal outcomes
• Makes errors
• Operates within economic systems

From grade school we learn that science grows through questioning.

It does not require silence.

No Civilization Owns Healing Wisdom

As the world joins voices, we must grow in healing wisdom.

Long before modern Western medicine:

• Cultures understood adolescence
• Healers treated emotional distress
• Communities navigated identity transitions
• Traditions developed holistic frameworks of care

To behave as though legitimate knowledge began in Western clinical spaces is not science.

It is cultural amnesia.

It raises a necessary question:

How did humanity survive before we arrived?

When Other Expertise Is Dismissed

Families often encounter an unsettling dynamic:

• Psychological care minimized
• Developmental perspectives sidelined
• Holistic practitioners dismissed
• Alternative therapeutic approaches ridiculed

As though healing has a single sanctioned language.

Yet medicine itself routinely acknowledges:

✔ Multidisciplinary care
✔ Mental health integration
✔ Social determinants of health
✔ Individual variation

Why, then, does nuance sometimes vanish in certain debates?

Where Trust Becomes Fragile

Trust is healthiest when it is:

✔ Informed
✔ Engaged
✔ Curious
✔ Willing to ask difficult questions

Not when it becomes automatic compliance. Doctrine.

Especially when children are involved.
Especially when long-term outcomes are still being studied.
Especially when interventions may carry lasting effects.

And Yes — We Must Name the Greed

Unfortunately, current medical systems exist within profit-driven structures.

This is not accusation.
This is observable reality.

• Pharmaceutical incentives
• Insurance pressures
• Market expansion
• Financial conflicts

Acknowledging this does not invalidate medicine.

It resists naïveté.

Because when profit and power intersect with human vulnerability, scrutiny is not hostility.

It is responsibility.

Progress Without Scrutiny Is Not Progress

Any movement that discourages critical examination of powerful systems — including medical systems — is not advancing justice.

It is protecting authority from discomfort.

Medical systems save lives.
Medical systems also carry bias, limits, and economic motives.

Both truths coexist.

Only one is often treated as unspeakable.

The Real Question

Not:

“Why question Western medicine?”

But:

“Who benefits when people feel forbidden from doing so?”

Borrowing the language of Black struggle is easy.

Living the practice of Black truth-telling — especially when institutions, expertise, and power are involved — is the part many hesitate to embody. It is a difficult road. You will be framed as the “big-mouthed, angry, villain and the enemy.”

You will probably lose “friends” and opportunities. Oh, yes.

But, that hesitation to embody the practice is exactly why the distinction matters.